NABBING ASSETS BEFORE THEY'RE EATEN UP
You have gone through the full legal process, won your client's case and obtained a substantial judgment. All you have to do is levy the assets of the other party and reap the rewards. But is it that easy?
You've perfected your judgment, the opposing party refuses to pay the debt, and the sheriff or constable cannot find sufficient assets to satisfy the judgment. What happens next?
Most attorneys first try to depose the other parties in a postjudgment discovery action to determine their net worth and then locate the source of assets. You should require the opposing parties to present their financial statements, tax returns and bank statements. Also, question subjects about their income and personal and business assets.
During this postjudgment discovery, many attorneys find that the opposing parties have already hidden their assets. Subjects may have either taken the money offshore or transferred it to other entities, such as their children's or family trusts. Or they may have hidden it using another name, such as the spouse's maiden name. Assets will be there nine times out of ten.
In 20 years of investigation, I have heard almost every story about how people have lost their assets and now can't pay the judgment. Typical stories include: "I went to Las Vegas (or Atlantic City) and lost it all gambling." "My wife and I used the money to live on and spent it all." "My bookkeeper or accountant stole the money." "I lost it all on bad business deals trying to raise the money to pay this judgment."
You may have heard similar stories and found that the parties could not document their claims. Let me offer a few suggestions that may show you where the money has really gone.
· Check to see if the subjects made large payments on their home mortgages during the period of your lawsuit, especially in the last year of the lawsuit. Many people try to hide their assets by paying on their mortgage and adding to the equity of their homes which they believe to be "bullet-proof" in Texas because of the homestead law.
· Examine the payment of their universal life or whole life insurance policies. A prepayment can accrue interest just like a savings account and doesn't show up on financial records except inside the insurance policy itself.
· Look for savings bond purchases, either in the subject's names, their children's names or the spouse's maiden name. Until recently, these transactions were not registered centrally and were a favorite purchase of money launderers and drug dealers.
· Look for cashier's check purchases in the bank accounts of your party. These checks can be purchased and tucked away for the future just like cash.
When you bring opposing parties to depositions, instruct them to bring the kind of documents that will help you and your investigator trace their financial history. This is one of the most overlooked areas of discovery because attorneys frequently don't understand the process of investigation.
Where a person went and who they spoke to or dealt with is often more important than knowing about their business and where their money was when those last financial statements and tax returns were filed. Sometimes the most crucial evidence can be found by tracing certain activities. Timing of these activities may prove that financial transactions were made to protect personal assets.
The following key documents may reveal a person's hidden assets. They may also help prove the intent of hiding these assets from the court.
By documenting financial withdrawals from bank accounts and timing them with trips to foreign countries, you can often discover offshore fund transfers.
For example, I know an accountant who made a trip to the Cayman Islands every month with his scuba gear. It took US customs three years to figure out his tanks were filled with $100 bills.
If you want to find an undisclosed business partner or a "significant other" in a relationship, try subpoenaing the car phone records. Compare the numbers and names on the bills against the people that are known to your clients. I promise you will find some interesting information.
CREDIT CARD STATEMENTS
CREDIT REPORTING AGENCIES
All of the records listed are easy to obtain, particularly under a motion to produce. If you find that the opposing party is unwilling or unable to gather these documents, you should think about subpoenaing these records directly from the sources that produced them.
In many cases, once these records have been requested, obstinate parties suddenly become much more amenable to resolving financial issues and settling their judgments. If they have anything to hide, they would much rather settle with you, an obviously experienced investigator than produce these records publicly for other creditors to find as well.
The next time you go in to postjudgment discovery, or if you want to find the financial worth and assets of parties earlier on in a case, consider these ideas and resources for your legal strategy.
ASSETS - FINANCIAL INVESTIGITONS
AND COLLECTIONS LIBRARY
Thomas Investigative Publications, Inc.
P O Box 82148, Austin Texas, 78708
Phone 512-719-3595 Fax 512-719-3594
All rights reserved.