Document and Handwriting Analysis Basics for PIs

In the realm of private investigation, documents often hold silent yet profound clues. From contracts and letters to anonymous notes and financial records, written or printed materials can be pivotal pieces of evidence. Understanding the basics of document and handwriting analysis can equip private investigators to spot potential red flags, gather preliminary insights, and crucially, know when to bring in the specialized expertise of a Forensic Document Examiner (FDE). This article will guide you through the foundational elements of examining documents for authenticity, alterations, and the stories handwriting can tell.

What is Document Examination? More Than Just Handwriting

Document examination is a broad field that encompasses much more than just comparing signatures. It involves the scientific scrutiny of a document to determine its origin, authenticity, history, and to uncover any alterations or anomalies. This can include analyzing:

• Paper: Type, watermarks, thickness, fluorescence under UV light.
• Ink: Color, type (ballpoint, gel, fountain pen), and chemical properties (usually an FDE task).
• Printing Processes: Typewriter, inkjet, laser printer, commercial printing – each has unique characteristics.
• Handwriting and Signatures: Comparing letter formations, slant, spacing, pressure, and other individual traits.
• Alterations: Erasures, additions, obliterations, and page substitutions.
• Indentations: Latent impressions left on pages below the one written on.
• Damage: Tears, stains, or burns that might be relevant to the case.

Initial Document Assessment: What PIs Can Look For

While PIs are not expected to be forensic document examiners, a keen observational eye can identify many preliminary issues that warrant further investigation.

1. Assessing Authenticity:

• Obvious Forgeries/Copies: Is the document an original, or does it show signs of being a photocopy when an original is expected (e.g., lack of texture, flat signature)?
• Consistency: In a multi-page document or one allegedly produced at a specific time, are the fonts, printing methods, and layout consistent throughout? Do they align with the purported age of the document?
• Security Features: For official documents (IDs, certificates, etc.), familiarize yourself with known security features. While PIs typically don’t authenticate currency, understanding that such features exist (watermarks, microprinting, special threads) is a good principle.

2. Spotting Potential Alterations:

• Erasures: Look for thinned areas of the paper, smudged ink, or disturbed paper fibers. An abrasive eraser can leave visible damage.
• Obliterations: Has something been written over or covered up with correction fluid/tape? Sometimes, the original writing can be deciphered using strong backlighting or by looking for differences in ink sheen or texture.
• Additions: Does any text appear squeezed in, misaligned with other text, or written in a different ink or penmanship? Pay attention to line spacing and margins.
• Page Substitutions: In documents like wills or contracts, check for consistency in paper type, size, color, and the alignment of staple holes or binding.

3. Preliminary Handwriting Observations: It’s crucial to understand that definitive handwriting identification is the domain of FDEs. However, PIs can look for:

• Obvious Discrepancies: When comparing a questioned document with known genuine samples (exemplars) from the same individual, are there glaring, fundamental differences in letter shapes, style, slant, or overall flow? This doesn’t confirm forgery but certainly raises a question.
• Signs of Unnatural Writing: Writing that appears slowly drawn, shaky (when not attributable to age or illness), contains unusual pen lifts in the middle of words or letters, or looks like it was traced can be suspicious.

Essential Tools for a PI’s Preliminary Look

While FDEs use sophisticated laboratory equipment, PIs can benefit from some basic tools for initial examination:

• A good quality magnifying glass or a digital microscope can be indispensable for examining fine details like paper fibers, ink characteristics, and subtle signs of alteration.
• Adequate lighting is key. An adjustable lamp that allows for direct and oblique lighting (shining the light source at a low angle across the document surface) can help reveal indentations, erasures, and surface irregularities not easily seen otherwise.
• When handling potentially important documents, using cotton gloves can prevent the addition of your own fingerprints or oils.
• Before any intensive examination, always document the document’s initial state with high-resolution photographs or scans. Using a reliable digital camera or a flatbed scanner ensures you have a clear record.

PI Mall offers a range of magnification tools and general evidence handling supplies that can aid in these preliminary assessments.

What PIs Should Not Do

It’s vital to recognize the limits of your expertise:

• Avoid Definitive Conclusions: Do not state that a signature is a forgery or that a document has been altered based solely on your preliminary examination. Phrase your findings as observations (e.g., “The signature on document A appears to differ significantly in formation from the known signatures on documents B and C.”).
• No Chemical Testing: Never attempt to apply chemicals to analyze inks or paper. This can damage the document and compromise further expert analysis.
• Preserve the Evidence: Handle original documents with extreme care. Do not fold, tear, mark, or otherwise damage them. Use archival-quality sleeves or page protectors for storage.

When to Call in the Expert: The Forensic Document Examiner (FDE)

Your role as a PI is often to identify when a deeper, scientific analysis is necessary. Engage a qualified FDE when:

• A definitive opinion on a document’s authenticity or the authorship of handwriting/signatures is required for your case, especially if it may go to court.
• You suspect alterations that are not immediately obvious (e.g., different inks that look similar to the naked eye, skillfully inserted pages).
• The document’s integrity is a central point of contention in a legal dispute.

FDEs use specialized equipment (microscopes, infrared and ultraviolet light sources, electrostatic detection apparatus for indentations, etc.) and scientific methodologies to conduct their examinations. They can compare questioned documents with known specimens and provide expert opinions and testimony.

Collecting and Preserving Document Evidence

• Handle with Care: Minimize handling of original documents.
• Protect from Contamination: Store documents in clean, dry environments, away from direct sunlight, moisture, and extreme temperatures.
• Maintain Chain of Custody: If the document is evidence for a legal case, meticulously document its handling and possession.
• Use High-Quality Copies: For your working needs, use high-quality photocopies or digital scans of the original.

A Note on Handwriting: FDE vs. Graphology

Forensic handwriting analysis performed by an FDE focuses on identifying or eliminating individuals as the writer of a particular text or signature. It’s a comparative science based on the principle that everyone’s handwriting contains unique, individual characteristics. FDEs compare elements like letter formation, slant, spacing, alignment, pressure, and connecting strokes.

This is distinctly different from graphology, which attempts to determine personality traits from handwriting. While graphology may be of interest to some, it is not typically used in forensic or legal settings for writer identification.

By understanding these basics, PIs can more effectively evaluate documentary evidence, make informed decisions about their investigative next steps, and ensure that critical evidence is properly handled and, when necessary, expertly analyzed.

---

Need to take a closer look at the documents in your case? Find high-quality magnification tools and evidence handling supplies in our extensive catalog at PI Mall.